357 sig vs 9mm recoil

Stopping Power and Ballistics. It’s a good thing you purchased both and found a purpose for each of them. If it did law enforcement agencies all over the country would’ve switched to it. And don’t even get me started on the 960 Rowland. It wasn’t uncommon to dig out bullets varying in power including 357 Mag, 45ACP 44 Mag and a few 9mm. BUT the straight case design of these two calibers makes the cartridges ~6.2% thinner, allowing for one to two additional rounds in the mag. Looking at the 7.65x21mm’s and the 9x19mm’s ballistics performance, it’s obvious that the former is superior. Does the 5.7x28mm recoil harder? Based on the values you provided, the .45 ACP has a recoil value of 1.03 the .357 Sig's is .90. http://www.answers.com/Q/What_gun_is_carried_by_secret_service_agents. Whether or not it’ll be worth getting the conversion barrel depends on the barrel length of your particular Shield model. In the 9-to-40 comparison, we have a smaller, lighter bullet versus a slower, heavier one. It recoils strongly, has lesser capacity in same-size guns and may be hard on guns. I was pleased to find the .357 Sig is easier for me to shoot. Thumbnail: shootout with a Meth Head blasting us, he was hit 9 times within 12-15 feet, both lungs punched out, one hit through the neck severing his carotid artery and he ran like a zombie in WW 3 MOVIE. I’ve been hunting for a place such as this for quite a long moment. A cartridge equal to .357 Mag ballistics in guns that provide double the capacity Handgun Recoil Table By Chuck Hawks . Unfortunately that’s the only thing it has going for it. Show me a mid sized gun that can chamber a 38 super or 9×23, the 20111’s STI style guns are HUGE. Trajectories change a lot on glass, and with the supports inside a car door, 9mm and .40 can be stopped dead in its tracks. In other words the typical 125-grain JHP load travels 250 fps faster in a 357 Sig than in a 9 mm Luger. Colt Python Earns Top-Selling Revolver Slot in 2020, Collier & Colt: The Origins of the Revolver, Origins of Pistolcraft: The Development of the 'Modern Technique', © 2021 National Rifle Association of America. The .357 Sig uses a .355 inch diameter bullet like the 9mm, not a .357 diameter bullet like the .357 Magnum and .38 Special. As stated, the recoil is roughly similar to the .40 S&W, but certainly less than the … I think carrying typical 125-grain .357 SIG loads is pushing it — I can be wrong as I’ve never had to shoot a bear before, but in such scenarios it’s better to err on the safe side. The 19 being the same size and feel as the 32 is still used for high volume range time. Join 70,000 Readers For Our Weekly Discounts. Actually one of the original design criteria’s for the 5.7x28mm was to reduce the recoil impulse compared to the 9mm NATO. There is a clear speed advantage to the Sig, not at all surprising in view of the larger case capacity. GND is community supported. Scant amounts of .40S&W, .45 ACP, and a relatively available amount of the obscure and much maligned .357 SIG. It differs in that it is uses a bottlenecked case developed from the .40 S&W. The Great Ammo Shortage of 2020: When Will It End? Seeing how it’s still in use today in several countries’ military and law enforcement, the 9mm would probably continue to be a popular choice for handgunners for a hundred years more, notwithstanding threats from new contenders like the wildcat  .22 Tuason Craig Micromagnum (.22 TCM) and the still unnamed 7.5mm cartridge for what is arguably the most powerful semi-automatic production handgun yet, the 7.5 FK BRNO. In the shooting sports we call that reaction recoil or "kick." Cheers! Recoil plays a part in this ability by causing your muzzle to climb with every successive shot fired. Why? They looked at the 10mm and accepted a bullet redesigned as the .40 S&W. Smaller, weaker, and less-experienced handgun users should generally start with a round that gives you less recoil, which in this case is (usually) the .357 SIG. To me, if the shoe fits, wear it. To use the logic that 9mm is as good as the .357 Sig is the same as saying the .38 Special is as good as the .357 Magnum. As for the phasers, you’re right where that’s concerned too. Just look at how now there a making 45acp + p rounds and 40SW rounds going 50-75 FPS faster and that’s something that was never heard of ten years ago. Is it more expensive? Among other advantages, this means the gun’s breech dimensions and magazines are the same as the .40’s. The little round came into its own in the 70s when modern JHP ammo was developed. It’s simply easier. ? https://www.turners.com/kimber/kimber-pro-carry-hd-ii-38-supe-5612. The bean counters had a hissy over the cost of 10mm and convinced command to go to .45 Glock 21SF with Golden Sabres and a +P. I’m another latecomer to the article/party. I currently carry a p229 chambered in .357 sig. It’s just too easy. I’m not sure where you got your info, but when you said “The 10mm was their second hope followed by the .40.” I took it you implied that the .357 SIG came before the 10mm? Anonymous. After research I determined that if I ever had to defend myself I would want the upper hand. 4. They advertise 1475fps, for 357sig but it chronos at 1500+ untill you put it in a Glock 33 then it comes in at advertised or slightly under. Actually, the blast does contribute to recoil. Thays just fine with me. If it’s good enough to guard the President, it’s good enough for me. I’ve been looking a lot at Smith & Wesson’s website lately and I believe they have subcompact (~3-inch), compact and full-size Shield models. And thank you for taking the time to read through it all, Joe. The odds of myself having to fire on, more so through a car door or windshield , vs the average person is pretty large. I’m pretty sure the 124 grain Federal HST’s stuffed in it will give a bad guy a real bad case of heartburn and indigestion. Since durable steel handguns that can use 9mm +P+ loads are cheaper and more readily available, Two other strong contenders in the .355-caliber 125-bullet weight division are the .38 Super and the. Hi, I am just an average guy with a CHL. 45 ACP vs 9mm Recoil. I wish there could be more odd ones like yourself — then maybe the .357 SIG would get the popularity it deserves. Them phasers won’t be coming out for prolly a couple hundred years more — we’ll never see the end of the caliber wars in our lifetime . In a perfect world where money is never going to be an issue, I’d tell anyone who asks for a recommendation to buy any handgun chambered for this round if only to give it the chance it deserves. Still, the 9 mm has some advantages in easier shooting and training, as well as lower cost and longer gun life. A cartridge that had less recoil than .357 Magnum If I want a “+P” 357 Sig I can purchase Underwood’s loading of Gold Dot which hits 1510 FPS. If we follow this type of reasoning to its logical conclusion, that the extra 100 to 400 FPS really doesn’t matter, then I could make the argument that 9mm isn’t needed because we have the 380. In the 147-grain bullets, the 9 mm drives bullets to about 1,000 fps, while the .357 Sig does about 1,225, some 125 fps faster. That being said, I personally choose 357 Sig over 40S&W because it shoots flatter which means more accuracy for me. The company I purchased from also had a .357sig barrel. Gotta love ’em SIGs. The slight drawback of the 9mm +P+ having a bit of a lower velocity is mitigated by the fact that durable all-steel guns (e.g. However, the highest-cost for the 9mm Luger was $1.95, while the highest per-round price for.357 Magnum was $1.90. Anyway, thank you for the reply and a great article. I totally agree my friend. No question, the caliber wars will continue as long as firearms are being used. 6 years ago. Because it didn’t really catch on as far as popularity, partly due to it being released just a few years after the .40 S&W and partly due to it not really having any practical advantages over other more established handgun calibers, ammo availability tends to be an issue in some states. I own a S&W shield in .40. Don’t get me wrong, I have a Glock 33 in 357 Sig and I love it! It is a no joke round with not only great terminal ballistics but incredible feeding reliability due to the bottleneck design. Privacy Policy   •   Contact Us   •   Warnings   •   FAQs   •  © 2021 National Rifle Association of America, Women On Target® Instructional Shooting Clinics, Volunteer At The Great American Outdoor Show, Marion P. Hammer Women Of Distinction Award, Women's Wildlife Management / Conservation Scholarship, National Youth Shooting Sports Ambassadors, NRA Outstanding Achievement Youth Award Presented by Brownells, National Youth Shooting Sports Cooperative Program, Marlin Model 1895: Top-Selling Lever-Action Rifle of 2020, Colt's Model 1855 Revolving Rifle in the Civil War. You might also favor a .38 Special for times when the frame or component parts of the gun are not compatible with +P or Magnum loads, so you can shoot standard ammunition. We recently went back to 9mm from .40 and everyone prefers the 9mm. We may earn a commission when you purchase through one of our links. As I also put on the list of reasons why I think it didn’t catch on, a lot of other more common calibers with similar or better ballistics are more prevalent due to better availability/ease of handloading: the .38 Super and 9×23 Winchester, some super hot 9mm +P+ loads, not to mention the 960 Rowland which, at the time of the article’s writing I haven’t heard of — is a newer wildcat more powerful than the .357 SIG as it was supposedly designed to mimic true .357 magnum performance. I have both….carry both at times because for me I interpreted the creation of the .357Sig for a specialized reason. Get the American Rifleman Insider newsletter for at-a-glance access to industry news, gear, gun reviews, videos and more—delivered directly to your Inbox. But it’s really up to you. What about recoil? I have a sig 229 in 40 cal, and I also have a 357 sig match barrel that swaps out with the 40 cal so I shoot both through the same frame, and I prefer shooting 40 cal over the 357 sig rounds just because recoil recovery takes less effort when shooting the .40. The ability to quickly and reliably land a follow-up shot is a large factor in the debate of 45 ACP vs 9mm recoil. Since then, I’ve acquired a P239(for carry) and a P229(for my wife.) That does not make it a better cartridge. So the argument my .45 is so much bigger and better than your 9mm is not only silly, but the actual difference in diameter is 9.6 caliber, less than 1/2 the diameter of a .22 bullet. I’ve been a Armed Security patrol officer for over a decade, carried everything from Sig p220s, 226s, 229s, Hk USPs, M9s, old steel 3rd gen Smith’s and every caliber from 9mm to .45ACP including the failed .45GAP. Heck yes. To each their own. A new ammo maker burst onto the scene, in the form of the .300 Blackout. 1. stopping power equal to the .357 Magnum, the cartridge Evan Marshall and Ed Sanow deemed, in their book “Handgun Stooping Power”, best manstopper in actual shootings, I’m sure all of you (and maybe a few of you participated too) had noticed that 9mm rounds were being gobbled up like tiny white marbles in a frantic game of hungry hungry hippos. A lot has to do with where I’m going and doing. Your comment made my day. Thank you for the entertaining article. With greater case capacity of modern powders, the .357 Sig is a very hot number. While the bullet diameter is the same as the wonder nine, most .357 Sig projectiles are shaped differently. Me personally I have thinned out my heard of 9mm pistols in favor of a few 357sig pistols. Stay safe and best wishes to you and my apologies for not responding sooner. 17 Okt 2016 #4. Since its release some 23 years ago, the .357 SIG has had a small but loyal (even die-hard) fan base — “small” being the operative word. Since the ammo availability issue has plagued the .357 SIG’s for so long because its popularity didn’t catch on, handgunners would naturally resort to handloading. this leaves guns like the 10mm glock 20’s, they are bigger, breach face is still 40/357/10mm brass sized, too large for extraction 100% of the time, mag lips are an issue. I attended an industry shoot in Las Vegas about 10 years ago and was the only carrier of a 357 SIG (my agency, and many more, despite what you’ve heard DID adopt the 357 SIG because it is a bad a$$ round). And the G42 is smaller and lighter than the G19 so why bother; right? auch .357" sind "nur" 9mm (genau gesagt: 9,07mm zu 9,02mm). And shorter barrel = bigger muzzle blast, even worse than what Jason above has touched on in his comment. They make some good 9mm loads, but they make even better 357 Sig. ThePersonalProtectionSpecialist is correct in all he said. I think the phrase “second hope” with regards to the FBI was their move away from .45 ACP. If you read the entirety of my article (I’m assuming you didn’t — otherwise you wouldn’t have taken too much time typing your long anti-9mm rhetoric), you’ll know that I don’t like the 9mm. As for ammo availability, I’ve got about 1800 to 2000 rounds of it and never had an issue finding it here in Texas. The new cartridge was designed to be used for semi-auto pistols because of the platform’s inherent advantages over revolvers: In 1994, it was introduced as the .357 SIG. First used by the German Navy in 1904, the 9 mm Luger (or Parabellum, etc.) Handgun Caliber Showdown Round 1: 9mm vs .357 SIG. In turn, out of guns of equal weight the.380 produces nearly half the recoil energy. And since it’s only been popular for, well, close to a hundred years (if we consider that it only really became widely accepted after World War I), guns and ammo availability for this caliber will never be an issue. So a 9mm Luger (Parabellum) round exits the barrel with kinetic energy equal to the energy required for linear vertical displacement of 360 pounds through a one foot distance, while a .357 SIG round exiting the barrel has energy equal to the amount required to displace 520 pounds over the same one foot distance. Follow up shots are so easy and their are plenty of times we have to shot one handed due to carrying shields or entry tools. Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear. I had read that the .357 Sig had less felt recoil than the .40 S&W, but I had never shot the two one right after the other to really try to judge them for myself. has a long service history and is probably the most widely used pistol cartridge in the world. In that same year the Smith & Wesson Registered Magnum (M27) was born. The average velocity for all loads at this weight is about 1,100 fps. A cartridge that could be shot out of a gun the size of 9mm, smaller and lighter than the .45acp.357 Mag and 10mms of that period. There is an enormous array of 124-grain ammo in 9 mm, including some +P and +P+ that is extra hot. As of writing this article, the lowest per-round cost for the 9mm was $0.14, while the lowest per-round for the.357 Magnum was $0.27. Mitglied seit 4 Mrz 2013 Beiträge 4 Gefällt mir 0. jacketed hollow points (JHPs) and jacketed soft points (JSPs) both can be great man-stoppers. .357 SIG vs .40 S&W. I always looked at it as a slightly watered down .357 mag. Not that I ever want to be in a gunfight. Your email address will not be published. Where the two differ greatly are their bullet velocities, their case dimensions and some would argue, what they can be used for. Despite the name, the actual bullet diameter is 9 mm (.355 inches). 5.7x28mm VS 9mm Recoil Impulse. Everyone says the .357 sig is a 9mm on steroids. I'm looking at buying my first handgun and was able to shot the smith and wesson m&p 9mm and liked it. How hard does the 5.7x28mm kick compared to the 9mm? (Both were FMJ rounds from Tula Ammo.) R. rome107. I guess this has to be the only exception (only downside is it costs an arm and a leg): For me the .357Sig advantage was always vehicle penetration. If it were true that 9mm +P rounds achieved the velocity reached by the 357 Sig, I wouldn’t have considered purchasing the G31. “Compared to a 9mm, the.357 Sig has a decreased magazine capacity, more recoil, as well as greater muzzle blast and flash, yet at best it offers no gain in bullet penetration and expansion characteristics. I believe the 9mm is the best carry caliber for most folk because, just as the FBI report stated, most are too recoil sensitive for anything more powerful (from 10mm to 40 Cal to 9mm). The automatic pistol is easier to use well in a personal defense situation, however. Hence, the 9mm was their “first hope” for a superior man-stopper bullet, and the 10mm became the “second hope”. I’ve had a few others that I didn’t keep, because I didn’t care for the gun itself. Love the caliber. The high-pressure rating of the brass can also push the typical 115-grain .355 caliber projectile out of a 4.65-inch barrel with muzzle velocities of up to 1,180 feet per second. Why, if that were the case, then I say we get rid of all types of ammo save the almighty .50 BMG, gather them and burn them all. What is the point of this cartridge?” He’s not the first person to ask that question. I never once said the 9mm is perfect. Lack of ammo availability? My background is a swat police officer in a major US city for clarification. But I digress.eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'gunnewsdaily_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_2',130,'0','0'])); So, for this handgun caliber showdown, it is with much sorrow and misery that I have to say that for all intents and purposes, the time-tested, relatively weaker but more readily available and more affordable 9mm wins over the .357 SIG. I’m one of those guys that carriers a different gun and caliber every week just for fun, but if I’m going to a bad part of town or on a trip, it’s the 357 SIG for all the reasons ThePersonalProtectionSpecialist mentioned. 357 Sig Vs 9mm. I’m not suggesting that everyone just carry a .22, but, if it’s all you have, it beats throwing rocks. To reiterate what I wrote in the Conclusion part of the article, I wish the .357 SIG gained the popularity that I think it deserves, I really do. I think as a concept, it works great. I’d love to have a Coonan in .357 magnum too. Our practice of head shots became a training focus afterwards whereas before we were trained center mass. Heavier 147-grain JHPs are becoming more popular. I’ve been a few shootouts over 30 years as a cop. I’m cracking up on the heartburn/indigestion bit, lol. The .357 Sig was developed to offer the best of all worlds; Required fields are marked *. The best way to examine any potential differences in power between the 9mm and .357 SIG is by comparing ballistics gel testing data. Its one part of the 'ejecta', which means the stuff leaving the gun. Ahhh so many guns, so little time. Maybe at some local gunstores. .357 Sig was out of the running. Why is that even a question? 6 rounds of .357 mag or 16 of .357 sig? Where as my Glock 19 was the equalizer, the Glock 32 that I have made my EDC gives me more comfort. If you look at this link http://www.ballisticsbytheinch.com/357sig.html you’ll see that there’s around ~200 fps difference in muzzle velocities when firing any of the specified .357 SIG loads from a 3-inch and a 5-inch. Felt recoil is different for each person, what is excessive for me might not be for you and vice versa." Although made with typical 115-grain bullets for many years, the most commonly used 9 mm Luger bullet today weighs 124 grains. I don’t see this point in most discrediting articles for the cartridge. Was wiederum beweist: Treffen ist das beste Kaliber Gesendet von meinem D5803 mit Tapatalk . That’s what matters most for me. After they got their asses beat in a gunfight in 1986, due mostly to poor operator performance, they dropped the 9mm like a hot potato and restarted their search for a better operational bullet. Ed, thanks for reading the article. If that’s the case, that is inaccurate, as the 10mm was the mother cartridge of the .40 S&W, which came before the .357 SIG. Colder weather or woods carry it’s always a .357 sig. ;-) Grüße Sirius . But its biggest Achilles’ heel being it can be expensive/difficult to come by/hard to handload in my opinion makes it inferior than the readily available but ballistically weaker 9mm. Then there’s its sister and mother cartridges the .40 S&W and 10mm respectively, the magazines for which will fit the same number of rounds — the .40 being one of the three most common handgun calibers in the world (which the .357 SIG really should have rendered obsolete were it destined for greatness), there’s just no hope for the .357 SIG as far as popularity in the foreseeable future. Now look at the average velocity of an admittedly smaller assortment of .357 Sig ammo using bullets of the same weight. Also working outdoors in the woods of Maine, it has its merits against…larger wildlife that a 9mm, .40 or .45 would just piss off due to less penetration. I read an article from a trauma surgeon and he’s seen people killed with a single .22 caliber bullet and he’s also seen guys shot with a 10mm that ran away. I’ve had zero issues locating HSTs, Gold Dots, various brands of FMJ, reloads, etc. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. E-mail your comments/questions about this site to:EmediaRifleman@nrahq.org For questions/comments about American Rifleman magazine, please e-mail:Publications@nrahq.org You can contact the NRA via phone at: NRA Member Programs1-800-672-3888, To advertise on American Rifleman, visit nramediakit.com for more information. To be honest, there wasn’t any significant observable differences in the damage done. Which, in turn, led to an increase in sales of guns and barrels chambered for that round. Damian, thanks for reading the article. @Amado Garcia, thank you for the kind words. We plan to help you answer all those questions, this time around, we'll discus .40 S&W vs .357 Sig, two very capable self-defense cartridges. https://gunnewsdaily.com/fk-brno-field-pistol-review/. My first 357 sig purchase was a LEO trade in Glock 31 that I still own. Although we all have our “comfort” caliber, I could not agree more with your assessment. Thanks for your input. COVID-19 showed us that a sudden spike in demand for even the most mainstream and mass-produced types of cartridges, is still all it takes to create a shortage of said cartridge. 5. The .357 SIG was a little late in the party because when it came out, the FBI and a lot of other law enforcement agencies had already adopted the .40 S&W. And before I forget, I downloaded that link you sent and I’ll read it later today. The .357 SIG outperformed the 9mm, .40 S&W and the .45 ACP in higher percentage success rates in accuracy and the various training scenarios my father put me through. The brass was made 1/8-inch longer so it wouldn’t fit inside the weaker .38 Special revolvers’ chambers to avoid catastrophic results, and in 1935 it was christened the .357 S&W Magnum. I also noticed that you mentioned Underwood 9mm. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTTDgZZZFa0, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U4DsaBrohV0. There are pros and cons to both cartridges, as well as the .40 S&W, the .45 ACP, the 10mm, the .38 super, etc. I just bought a new sig in 45 and I really cannot feel any recoil until the last shot, when the slide stays open and the clip is emptied( gun lighted up) .My fatherinlaw has a S&W 357. Budget always controls preferences in the field. P320 Sub Compact SC Recoil Guide Rod Spring Assembly 9mm, 40S&W, 357 Sig, 3.6" From the .38 special, modifications began to be made by Phil Sharpe, Elmer Keith, and eventually the guys at Smith & Wesson. In other words the typical 125-grain JHP load travels 250 fps faster in a 357 Sig than in a 9 mm Luger. Where I work I am not allowed to carry a 686-2 so….the hardest hitting “duty caliber” round I can have is the .357SiG…..and honestly. $30-40 for 50 rounds of FMJ and astronomical prices for HPJ. Capable of good velocities, particularly with lighter bullets, the 9 mm cartridge is made for dozens of pistol designs. Our handguns are our secondary weapons not our primary. 357 Sig is one of my favorite cartridges, but my go to gun for EDC is my Glock 26 in 9mm. I have no interest whatsoever in being in a gunfight. Lol. You just earned your self a NEW fan. After the first round of tests everybody wanted me to go first because the force and cavitation shown by the dummy when shot by the 357 SIG was noticeably greater then all the other calibers. Recoil wise 357 sig feels very similar to .40s&w. The problem is the .357 SIG also has a reputation for being hard to reload, so while a few are able to successfully reload. Not sure why the .357 Sig is being evaluated as a hunting cartridge? This meant that most popular and cheapest of rounds was unavailable not only at your local gun shops and big box stores, but even online. There have been many times I asked myself this question: If I survived a holocaust of some sort — like say a zombie apocalypse or a nuclear fallout — and there was only one semi-auto handgun caliber left in the world, what would that be for me? ? You need a oal of 1.2 in for those to be at there peak power. Anyway, long story short, it’s right back to “WHERE” someone is shot, not the caliber. After research I determined that if I ever had to defend myself I would want the upper hand. To compare the 9 mm to the .357 Sig is an entirely different ball game. The 10mm was their second hope followed by the .40. ? A. anonym Guest. Gun News Daily is the longest running gun news website in the US. Using it skillfully takes practice and familiarity. That was back in the old days way before 10mm, 40S&W and 357SIG were developed and I was involved in taking care of shootout victims usually in “drug deals gone bad” – AKA victims of LEO including State Patrol, DEA, etc. Most agencies in our areas had the Glock 22 / .40 so we were told to accept the .45+p

Uquiz Haikyuu Parents, Dr Jart Color Correcting Cream Canada, Amniotic Fluid Color, Scorpion Stage Fatality Mkx, Kansas City Hot Dog, All Miraculous Jewels Names, Fulton Boiler Parts List, Triple Monitor Wallpaper 5760x1200, Sidi Cycling Shoes Clearance,